Question for the geologists....if there are any
Moderator: CameronBornAndBred
- CameronBornAndBred
- PWing School Chancellor
- Posts: 16139
- Joined: April 8th, 2009, 7:03 pm
- Location: New Bern, NC
- Contact:
Question for the geologists....if there are any
As I was flying out west, I was noticing the desert floor and thinking..."Where the hell are the craters?"
The earth gets bombarded daily by literal tons of debris from space, and every few hundred or thousand years one makes it through that leaves a mark. If you look at Mars (which looks like our desert) it's an obvious comparison. The earth of course has one big thing that Mars doesn't (anymore) and that's water. So I get that over millions of years a crater could get filled in. Also, the American desert wasn't always a desert, it was an ocean at some point too...so that means LOTS of water. But still, it's been a desert for a LOOOOONG time, so I would expect to see evidence of some recent impacts.
Anyways..I was looking, and hard, and didn't find squat. Until. I spotted this beauty, but it has another possible explanation. It is possible that this is from volcanic activity...there was way more than I knew or expected. Where I spent my first day hiking outside of Vegas, the Valley of Fire, is largely the result of volcanic activity. Anyways..all I can tell you about this crater is that it was east of the Grand Canyon but west of the mountains.
The earth gets bombarded daily by literal tons of debris from space, and every few hundred or thousand years one makes it through that leaves a mark. If you look at Mars (which looks like our desert) it's an obvious comparison. The earth of course has one big thing that Mars doesn't (anymore) and that's water. So I get that over millions of years a crater could get filled in. Also, the American desert wasn't always a desert, it was an ocean at some point too...so that means LOTS of water. But still, it's been a desert for a LOOOOONG time, so I would expect to see evidence of some recent impacts.
Anyways..I was looking, and hard, and didn't find squat. Until. I spotted this beauty, but it has another possible explanation. It is possible that this is from volcanic activity...there was way more than I knew or expected. Where I spent my first day hiking outside of Vegas, the Valley of Fire, is largely the result of volcanic activity. Anyways..all I can tell you about this crater is that it was east of the Grand Canyon but west of the mountains.
Duke born, Duke bred, cooking on a grill so I'm tailgate fed.
- EarlJam
- PWing School Associate Professor
- Posts: 3235
- Joined: April 9th, 2009, 2:58 pm
- Location: Atlanta, GA
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
VERY cool post and good question. I, of course, have not a clue as to the answer but totally appreciate the question.CameronBornAndBred wrote:As I was flying out west, I was noticing the desert floor and thinking..."Where the hell are the craters?"
The earth gets bombarded daily by literal tons of debris from space, and every few hundred or thousand years one makes it through that leaves a mark. If you look at Mars (which looks like our desert) it's an obvious comparison. The earth of course has one big thing that Mars doesn't (anymore) and that's water. So I get that over millions of years a crater could get filled in. Also, the American desert wasn't always a desert, it was an ocean at some point too...so that means LOTS of water. But still, it's been a desert for a LOOOOONG time, so I would expect to see evidence of some recent impacts.
Anyways..I was looking, and hard, and didn't find squat. Until. I spotted this beauty, but it has another possible explanation. It is possible that this is from volcanic activity...there was way more than I knew or expected. Where I spent my first day hiking outside of Vegas, the Valley of Fire, is largely the result of volcanic activity. Anyways..all I can tell you about this crater is that it was east of the Grand Canyon but west of the mountains.
I add: How "unique" is our atmospere? I know it works in large part as a missle (a.k.a. meteor) defense shield, but still objects get through. Does Mars have anything close to a similar atmosphere?
-EarlJam
Your mama wears combat boots to bed.
- YmoBeThere
- PWing School Endowed Professor
- Posts: 6912
- Joined: April 13th, 2009, 7:36 pm
- Location: South Central...Tejas
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
For some reason, I associate rthomas at that board over yonder with geology...
- Miles
- PWing School Associate Professor
- Posts: 3318
- Joined: April 10th, 2009, 9:55 pm
- Location: Charlotte, NC!!!
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
Mars' atmosphere contains less than 1% of the mass of Earth's atmosphere. It is extremely "thin", which doesn't provide an opportunity for meteors to generate friction and burn up as they enter the atmosphere.EarlJam wrote:VERY cool post and good question. I, of course, have not a clue as to the answer but totally appreciate the question.CameronBornAndBred wrote:As I was flying out west, I was noticing the desert floor and thinking..."Where the hell are the craters?"
The earth gets bombarded daily by literal tons of debris from space, and every few hundred or thousand years one makes it through that leaves a mark. If you look at Mars (which looks like our desert) it's an obvious comparison. The earth of course has one big thing that Mars doesn't (anymore) and that's water. So I get that over millions of years a crater could get filled in. Also, the American desert wasn't always a desert, it was an ocean at some point too...so that means LOTS of water. But still, it's been a desert for a LOOOOONG time, so I would expect to see evidence of some recent impacts.
Anyways..I was looking, and hard, and didn't find squat. Until. I spotted this beauty, but it has another possible explanation. It is possible that this is from volcanic activity...there was way more than I knew or expected. Where I spent my first day hiking outside of Vegas, the Valley of Fire, is largely the result of volcanic activity. Anyways..all I can tell you about this crater is that it was east of the Grand Canyon but west of the mountains.
I add: How "unique" is our atmospere? I know it works in large part as a missle (a.k.a. meteor) defense shield, but still objects get through. Does Mars have anything close to a similar atmosphere?
-EarlJam
It's hard to say how unique our atmosphere is. Given the size and scale of the universe, I feel like there have to be other atmospheres like ours. The real question is if we'll ever be able to find one and so far, the outlook is grim.
sMiles
- DukeUsul
- PWing School Assistant Professor
- Posts: 2390
- Joined: April 14th, 2009, 9:30 am
- Location: Back in the dirty Jerz
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
The Earth has a tremendous amount of surface activity that erodes craters. Wind, water and tectonic activity. Since our atmosphere burns up most meteors, only the real big ones leave big craters, anyway. And these are somewhat infrequent. On top of that, any of the real old ones have weathered so badly you can only see traces.
Conversely, a place like the moon with virtually no atmosphere and absolutely no erosion activity on the surface leads to a tremendous amount of visible craters.
According to this website, only about 120 terrestrial impact craters have been identified.
http://www.solarviews.com/eng/tercrate.htm
Conversely, a place like the moon with virtually no atmosphere and absolutely no erosion activity on the surface leads to a tremendous amount of visible craters.
According to this website, only about 120 terrestrial impact craters have been identified.
http://www.solarviews.com/eng/tercrate.htm
-- DukeUsul
- Miles
- PWing School Associate Professor
- Posts: 3318
- Joined: April 10th, 2009, 9:55 pm
- Location: Charlotte, NC!!!
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
Fun stuff CBaB. It looks like the Barringer Craterin Arizona. I went and saw it on my road trip across America. Unfortunately, I lost all the photos and their backups. I still have the video, which reminds me I need to transfer it.
As DukeUsul points out, there really aren't that many impact craters on Earth. You can find them all in the Earth Impact Database.
As DukeUsul points out, there really aren't that many impact craters on Earth. You can find them all in the Earth Impact Database.
sMiles
- CameronBornAndBred
- PWing School Chancellor
- Posts: 16139
- Joined: April 8th, 2009, 7:03 pm
- Location: New Bern, NC
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
Looks similar, but I don't think they are the same, the one I took the photo of seems to be more filled in. Here is another picture of Barringer.Miles wrote:Fun stuff CBaB. It looks like the Barringer Craterin Arizona. I went and saw it on my road trip across America. Unfortunately, I lost all the photos and their backups. I still have the video, which reminds me I need to transfer it.
As DukeUsul points out, there really aren't that many impact craters on Earth. You can find them all in the Earth Impact Database.
I think I will post this over yonder, too.
Duke born, Duke bred, cooking on a grill so I'm tailgate fed.
- Miles
- PWing School Associate Professor
- Posts: 3318
- Joined: April 10th, 2009, 9:55 pm
- Location: Charlotte, NC!!!
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
If it's not Barringer, then I'm sorry to say that it's probably not an impact crater.CameronBornAndBred wrote:Looks similar, but I don't think they are the same, the one I took the photo of seems to be more filled in. Here is another picture of Barringer.Miles wrote:Fun stuff CBaB. It looks like the Barringer Craterin Arizona. I went and saw it on my road trip across America. Unfortunately, I lost all the photos and their backups. I still have the video, which reminds me I need to transfer it.
As DukeUsul points out, there really aren't that many impact craters on Earth. You can find them all in the Earth Impact Database.
I think I will post this over yonder, too.
sMiles
- CameronBornAndBred
- PWing School Chancellor
- Posts: 16139
- Joined: April 8th, 2009, 7:03 pm
- Location: New Bern, NC
- Contact:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
Which is why vulcanism is an option. It could be a cauldron. Somebody knows!Miles wrote:If it's not Barringer, then I'm sorry to say that it's probably not an impact crater.CameronBornAndBred wrote:Looks similar, but I don't think they are the same, the one I took the photo of seems to be more filled in. Here is another picture of Barringer.Miles wrote:Fun stuff CBaB. It looks like the Barringer Craterin Arizona. I went and saw it on my road trip across America. Unfortunately, I lost all the photos and their backups. I still have the video, which reminds me I need to transfer it.
As DukeUsul points out, there really aren't that many impact craters on Earth. You can find them all in the Earth Impact Database.
I think I will post this over yonder, too.
Duke born, Duke bred, cooking on a grill so I'm tailgate fed.
- OZZIE4DUKE
- PWing School Chancellor
- Posts: 14460
- Joined: April 8th, 2009, 7:43 pm
- Location: Home! Watching carolina Go To Hell! :9f:
Re: Question for the geologists....if there are any
Calling Mr. Spock! Calling Mr. Spock!CameronBornAndBred wrote:
Which is why vulcanism is an option. It could be a cauldron. Somebody knows!
Your paradigm of optimism
Go To Hell carolina! Go To Hell!
9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F!
http://ecogreen.greentechaffiliate.com
Go To Hell carolina! Go To Hell!
9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F! 9F!
http://ecogreen.greentechaffiliate.com